Imagine a Christmas feast so unforgettable that your guests are still raving about the cheeseboard months later – but only if you get it just right! That's the magic of crafting the perfect holiday cheese spread, where every wedge tells a story of flavor and tradition. But here's where it gets intriguing: what if I told you that the key isn't just piling on the fanciest cheeses, but curating a board that's as thoughtful as it is delicious? Stick around, because we're diving into expert tips that will transform your festive table into a centerpiece of joy – and maybe even spark a few debates along the way.
What delights should grace my Christmas cheeseboard?
David, via email
It might not shock you to learn that Mathew Carver, the visionary behind Pick & Cheese (https://www.pickandcheese.com/), The Cheese Barge (https://www.thecheesebar.com/experiences/the-cheese-barge), and Rind (https://www.thecheesebar.com/experiences/rind), indulges in cheese on a grand scale. To keep his holiday selection from feeling routine, he often hones in on a particular area or locale: “For example, last Christmas in Scotland meant showcasing solely local varieties.” Wales is on his radar next. “I'm someone who sticks to favorites, so this approach nudges me to explore fresh discoveries,” he shares – and hey, it doesn't mean ditching a timeless option like Comté, especially for the holidays.
If you're not aiming for the extravagant gesture of spotlighting a single spectacular cheese, Bronwen Percival, technical director at Neal’s Yard Dairy (https://www.nealsyarddairy.co.uk/collections/christmas-cheese?gadsource=1&gadcampaignid=18741510953&gbraid=0AAAAADGi1Okvv7N4u3iCSrlmHPabXm3p&gclid=CjwKCAiA8vXIBhAtEiwAf3B-g-4E6VfT5yPkJOK7Qmh1wUtWoCo2d4EWVB9Y3YveEo3MeNILh9FL-BoCYNEQAvDBwE), recommends opting for three or four enticing wedges instead of thin slices from a multitude of choices. After all, most folks lack the patience for a setup demanding lengthy explanations. The secret lies in achieving harmony among varieties. “An ideal lineup of five would include a hard one, a soft one, a blue, a sheep's milk, and a goat's milk,” Carver suggests, allocating about 50-60g per guest. “Common advice hovers around 30-40g, but during Christmas, you want generous portions that exceed what you might reasonably consume.”
For beginners, let's break that down a bit: Hard cheeses, like aged cheddar, have a firm texture from pressing and aging, offering sharp, nutty flavors. Soft ones are creamy and spreadable, often with bloomy rinds from mold. Blues get their distinctive veins from beneficial mold, delivering tangy, piquant kicks. Sheep and goat's milks bring unique, tangy profiles – sheep's often earthier and sweeter, goat's lighter and more herbaceous. Balancing these ensures every bite offers contrast, from crumbly to gooey.
Now, on the specific cheeses to choose, Percival advocates for underrated regional gems that deserve more spotlight. Starting with Stonebeck Wensleydale (https://www.stonebeckcheese.co.uk/): “It's remarkably smooth and creamy, with notes that linger deliciously after the initial taste,” she describes. “It could completely change how you view Wensleydale.” Following that, Appleby’s Cheshire (https://www.applebysdairy.com/), which Percival praises as “juicy and mineral-rich, boasting a mild crumble and zesty citrus undertones. Pair a substantial piece with salted cultured butter and crackers for an unbeatable cheese course.” Enhance it with a splash of port or even kombucha for a surprising twist.
Then there's Mrs Kirkham’s Lancashire (https://www.mrskirkhamscheese.co.uk/), ideal for Christmas Eve alongside gingerbread or gingersnaps, according to Percival. Carver, meanwhile, has a soft spot for sheep's milk options: “The UK doesn't produce a ton of sheep's milk cheeses,” he notes, “but Wakebridge (https://wakebridgemanor.com/) from Derby echoes Lancashire or cheddar with a delightful natural sweetness.” To illustrate why regional cheeses shine, consider how local terroir – the unique soil, climate, and farming practices – infuses each one with distinct character, much like wines from specific vineyards.
But don't halt there; it's time to embellish, as Percival advises. Consider a plum and red onion chutney, a generous drizzle of premium honey, or spiced poached quinces, along with essential crackers (she favors sourdough and oatcakes for their hearty crunch). Carver leans toward more unconventional ideas: Picture a mild goat's cheese paired with rose-infused Turkish delight, or kimchi alongside Stilton for a bold kick. “Roast some garlic and blend it with honey into a paste, or whip up a simple parsnip puree – these would complement a soft, bloomy-rind cheese beautifully.”
And this is the part most people miss: when exactly to unveil that cheeseboard? While cheese is always in season, Percival prefers serving it early. “Back in the US, where I'm from, cheese often kicks off the meal as a nibble with sparkling drinks, priming the appetite rather than capping the feast.” Yet Carver stands firm on the post-dessert tradition: “I wrap up Christmas dinner around 4pm, indulge in chocolates for a while, then enjoy cheese and port by 6pm. That marks the end of the day for me.”
Now, here's a potentially divisive angle: Is the cheeseboard meant to be a humble appetizer or the grand finale? Percival's pre-meal approach emphasizes its role in building anticipation, like a teaser trailer for the main event. Carver's after-dessert stance treats it as a luxurious closer, letting sweeter notes give way to savory richness. Could this clash stem from cultural differences – American informality versus British ritual? What do you think: Should cheese whet the appetite or satisfy it? Drop your thoughts in the comments – do you side with early or late, or perhaps a compromise?
*
Facing a kitchen quandary? Shoot an email to feast@theguardian.com
